Skip to content
GateandGuard

05Windows, Doors, Fireplace & Edges

Windows, doors, the fireplace and every sharp edge: the fixes that fit your house

Screens don't hold a child, hearths crack heads and door levers open themselves. Here's what each hazard actually needs, with the picks for casement windows, brick hearths and rentals.

10 guides and picks in this section · How we choose

A living room with a brick fireplace and a large window
#ad

We earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. It never decides the ranking: the method is published. Affiliate disclosure

Start here

Read this first

A brick fireplace with a raised hearth in a living room

How to babyproof a fireplace: the hearth edge, the fire, and the glass you didn't think about

The three-part fireplace plan: hearth cushion for the edge, a hardware-mounted multi-panel gate at a manufacturer standoff for the season, and the specific rule for gas-fireplace glass, plus brick, ledge and stove variations.

Read it first

Featured pick: Toddleroo by North States 3-in-1 Metal Superyard

Check price on Amazon

#ad · Price set by Amazon · Affiliate disclosure for the link to Toddleroo by North States 3-in-1 Metal Superyard

Best picks

Ranked picks for this hazard

What to buy first

Whatever is between the child and a drop, a fire or a cord. This hub is five hazards that share a room rather than one product category, and the order is set by the injury data. Windows first: the CPSC counted about 5,600 children 12 and under treated for window falls in 2024, with one in three admitted, and at least 25 deaths from 2021 to 2023, most of them in the warm months when windows are open. A guard that states ASTM F2090 with an emergency release, or a stop that limits the opening to 4 inches, is the purchase, per how to childproof windows. Blind cords second, because the CPSC's count is about nine strangulation deaths a year in children under five and the fix is free: cut the loops, or wind them up, per blind cord safety. The fireplace third in season, the doors that lead somewhere dangerous fourth, and the corners all year.

How the category divides

Windows split into guards, which are bars that bolt to the frame and are the only product with a fall-prevention standard behind it, and stops, which limit how far a sash opens and are cheaper, no-drill and not a guard. The decision is window guards vs window stops and the ranking is best window guards and locks. Doors split by handle: a round knob takes a clip-on cover a small hand cannot grip; a lever takes an adhesive lock that pins it; both are ranked in best door locks and knob covers. The fireplace splits into the gate that stands off from the heat, in best fireplace baby gates, and the padding for the raised hearth, in best hearth pads and edge guards, with the whole room in how to babyproof a fireplace. Corners are foam or clear plastic, and the choice is about the surface and how visible you can stand it, in best corner guards and foam vs clear corner guards.

What decides the price

The window guard is the expensive item and the only one whose price buys a standard: Guardian Angel lists its F2090 guards at $89.99 to $114.99 per window by post height, and a Velcro window stop is a few dollars. The hearth gate is the other big number, at $274.95 for KidCo's, because it is a steel panel gate with a walk-through door that mounts to the wall on both sides and adjusts to 128 inches; a hearth cushion or 15 feet of Roving Cove edge foam ($25 at list) covers the edge but not the fire. Everything else in the hub is under $20: knob covers list $9.99 for a pack at Jool, a lever lock $19.99 at Wappa, corner guards $9 to $10 for eight to twelve. What you are paying for at the top of the range is a mounting system that survives a child's weight; what you are paying for at the bottom is adhesive, and adhesive is where the cheap products fail. Prices are maker list prices on the day we checked, linked on each spec table; Amazon sets its own.

The common mistake

Trusting the screen. An insect screen holds nothing; the CPSC's window guidance says so in as many words. The second is putting the crib, a chair or a toy box under the window, which turns a 36-inch sill into a 12-inch one; the CPSC's furniture-away-from-windows rule is the free fix. The third is a fireplace gate that touches the fireplace: the gate needs to stand off far enough that the child cannot reach the glass through it, because the CPSC puts the glass front of a gas fireplace at 500 to 1,000 degrees and the barrier rule that took effect in 2015 only covers new units. Fourth, corner guards on the coffee table and none on the raised hearth, which is at forehead height for a cruiser and made of stone. And the door mistake is covering the bathroom knob and leaving the door to the garage or the pool alone; the cover goes on the doors that lead somewhere dangerous, which are not always the ones you think of first.

Head to head

Comparisons

Guides

Guides: how to install it, and whether you need it

Filed elsewhere, written for you

Also worth reading

FAQ

Questions people ask

Do window screens prevent falls?
No. Screens keep insects out and hold no weight; the CPSC says not to rely on them. A window guard that states ASTM F2090 or a stop that limits the opening to 4 inches is the barrier.
Do I need a fireplace gate or a hearth pad?
Both if the fireplace is used: the gate stands the child off from the fire and the glass when it is lit; the pad covers the stone edge all year. A hearth pad alone does nothing about the heat.
Are blind cords still dangerous?
Yes, on older blinds. The CPSC counts about nine strangulation deaths a year in children under five; under the 2018 industry standard, stock blinds sold in the US are cordless or have inaccessible cords, but the ones already hanging need their loops cut or wound up.
Foam or clear corner guards?
Foam for wood and the hearth, where thickness matters more than looks; clear for glass and the surfaces you cannot stand to see padded. Both are adhesive; choose the tape for the finish.

Ask us

Got a hazard we haven't covered?

Tell us the room, the opening or the product you are stuck on. Reader questions decide what we research next. Email mike@blackironathletics.com or use the contact form.